Bab-ul-Ilm

Mumkin al-Wujud: Three Levels of Dependence; Quran 35:15 [from filename]

Session 11 — Modality and Causality (Al-Jiha, Wajib, Mumkin, 'Illah)

Listen in EnglishRead aloud by your device — pick a speed:

Three levels of dependence: Every Mumkin being depends on a cause — but dependence has levels. The slide title says there are three levels of dependence.

You are the Fuqara toward Allah: The Quran states the human side of it: "You are the Fuqara toward Allah" (35:15) — you are the poor, the needy, toward Allah. A Mumkin being is poor in its very existence: it owns nothing of itself, and every moment of its being is a gift from the cause that sustains it.

The three levels — to be verified: The three levels, as the course presents them, distinguish dependence in coming to be, dependence in remaining in being, and dependence in every attribute and action — but the exact three levels must be verified from the slide.

Example

The lamp and Faqr: A lamp depends on electricity to light, on the bulb to shine, and on the switch to stay on. A Mumkin being depends on its cause in every way at once — and the Quran calls that dependence "poverty" (Faqr).

Key Terms

  • Mumkin al-Wujud (ممکن الوجود) — Contingent Being
  • Faqr (الفقر) — poverty/neediness toward Allah

Quran or Hadith

Quran 35:15, as shown on the slide: "You are the Fuqara toward Allah." — to be checked.

Fresh diagram to be drawn: A three-level dependence diagram (levels to be confirmed from the slide). To be drawn in Project Desk colours.

Note: Slide 69 was not read; based on the filename. The exact three levels must be verified against the slide before publication.

💡 Remember:
  • Every Mumkin being depends on a cause — but dependence has levels.
  • A lamp depends on electricity to light, on the bulb to shine, and on the switch to stay on. A Mumkin being depends on its cause in every way at once — and the Quran calls that dependence "poverty" (Faqr).

Check your understanding

Total Marks: 3

Q1. Quran 35:15 says: "You are the Fuqara toward Allah." What does Fuqara mean here?(1 mark)

Q2. What does every Mumkin being depend on?(1 mark)

Q3. A Mumkin being owns its existence by itself.(1 mark)